Skip to content
Southampton playhouse
  • Showtimes
  • Membership
  • About
  • Support
  • Playhouse Post
  • Education
  • Rentals

Playhouse Post

’A Christmas Carol’ is a Horror Movie Now

November 15, 2026
Eric Kohn

Move aside, debates about whether Die Hard is a Christmas movie. It’s time to address whether A Christmas Carol is a horror movie. The latest version, Ebenezer, certainly presents itself in those terms. Johnny Depp’s grumpy embodiment of the rapacious antihero from Charles Dickens’ 1843 novel leans into the supernatural dread that haunts Ebenezer Scrooge as he confronts his nature. There are eerie jumpscares and ominous beings doused in black, children trapped in ghostly ribcages and a man-eating bed that recalls Depp’s fate decades ago in Nightmare on Elm Street.

Still, Ebenezer doesn’t exactly take a revisionist approach to the material. After all, the essence of the Dickens classic revolves around three ghosts haunting Scrooge over the course of existential Christmas Eve, as he confronts how his past actions set him up for his present grouchiness. Aside from a prologue that sketches out Scrooge’s initial dynamic with his since-deceased business partner Marley (Ian McKellan), Ebenezer follows that same redemptive arc, with all the seasonal uplift one expects this time of year.

“Before he was Scrooge, he was Ebenezer,” one of the taglines for the new movie, suggests the makings of an origin story. Instead, Ebenezer gets at the roots of the original material. While Nathaniel Halpern’s screenplay follows a straightforward path, director Ti West can’t help himself — in the best of ways — by piling on the Victorian creepiness of the material. For those unfamiliar, West has been cranking out original horror movies for two decades, including his most recent serial killer trilogy X, Pearl, and MaXXXine.

I’ve been a Ti West fan since the early days, when he was delivering slow-burn atmospheric thrillers such as The Roost, The House of the Devil, and The Innkeepers. West, who edits his own work with the sound on mute, excels at crafting a gradual sense of uneasiness that builds to various bloody conclusions. Ebenezer doesn’t go that far, but it certainly makes the case that horror lurks even in the innocuous realm of holiday cheer.

Ever since 1974’s Black Christmas, the horror genre has provided an ironic contrast to the upbeat nature of the season. There’s a whole mini-genre of Santa slasher movies, beginning with 1980’s Silent Night, Deadly Night, and the lasting appeal of The Nightmare Before Christmas speaks to the fundamental appeal of dark forces infiltrating Christmas bliss. As horror creeps into domestic spaces, the holiday milieu becomes a perfect target.

Horror is a mutable genre. In order to appeal to audiences beyond the diehards, it often has to be positioned in different terms. Obsession, the most successful horror movie of the year, was recently submitted to the Golden Globes as a comedy, following in the footsteps of Get Out in 2016. Elements of horror lurk in some of the biggest movies of the year, even if they don’t fall neatly into the expectations of the genre. That carnivorous cyclops in The Odyssey. Elizabeth Holmes’ eerie gaze in You Can See Everything. The shadow of Hiroshima in Godzilla Minus Zero.

Horror is an instinctive wakeup call. In A Christmas Carol, thanks to his hauntings, Scrooge comes to terms with his cruelty and figures out a better path forward. It’s a dramatic transformation, a challenge that Johnny Depp in Ebenezer leans into with visible glee, making the case that empathy lurks even in the darkest of souls once that darkness stares back at them. Most avaricious types don’t have the luxury of the hauntings that lead Scrooge to a better place. Redemption doesn’t come easy, and for many people, it doesn’t come at all. That’s the awful truth scarier than any of the horrors Dickens dreamed up.

Ebenezer is now showing at the Southampton Playhouse.

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading…
Black silhouette of a building with a peaked central roof on a white background

43 Hill Street, Southampton, NY 11968

  • Tickets Returns Exchanges
  • Accessibility
  • Legal
  • Mission
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • Letterboxd
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Youtube
  • X
  • FAQs

© Copyright 2025 Southampton Playhouse. All rights reserved.

%d